Sunday, December 1, 2013

1984 2.1-3 First Impressions of Julia

Julia is clever and bold in defying the Party. She fears the Party much less than Winston, and uses a more direct approach to get what she wants. Rather than waiting for a revolt, she secretly breaks rules and does not use Newspeak, which are her own small acts of rebellion. She is well-organized and driven when she plans the meeting place for Winston. She has good self-control to hide her feelings of hatred because she convinces people that she is an extremely devoted and enthusiastic Party member. She demonstrates that the Party's system of control is flawed. Although she has little memory of life before the Revolution and grew up under the reign of Big Brother, being taught throughout her life to support the Party, she still rebels against them. Even though she is much younger than Winston, she seems to share his experiences. It is strange that she acts understanding and even amused when Winston reveals that he had wanted to violently rape and murder her before he met her. She shows the Party cannot control human instinct by completely extinguishing the sex drive. She has had love affairs many times before with any Party member who is against Big Brother. She automatically calls Winston dear and is willing to let him do anything with her. She does not form a truly loving emotional connection, partially because of the limited time and freedom of the situation, which is what Winston had desired in his relationship with Katherine. When she describes her first affair, she indifferently says it is good that the man committed suicide, so he would not have confessed her name. At first, Julia is the girl of Winston's dreams, who tears of her clothes in the Golden Country, freeing herself from the Party. Yet, she seems too good to be true. I think there will be some conflict between Julia and Winston because she lives with the hope of happiness, while he believes they are defeated.

1 comment:

  1. Julia's strange approval of Winston's terrible thoughts toward her can be explained in part by her passionate desire for anything rebellious against the Party. Also, unlike Winston, she lives only for the moment, so it seems reasonable that she accepts the Party's assertion of doublethink and the idea that the past is controllable. Winston did not kill her, so now who cares, but she can manipulate his horrible feelings to draw out the only the concept of his rebellion, which she adores. Much of the difference between Winston's concern for the past and Julia's concern for the present may be the result of their ages. Winston was alive before the time of erasure of the past, or at least we get that impression, whereas Julia was not.

    ReplyDelete